By 1808Delaware

When internationally distributed newspaper 24/7 Wall Street chose its criteria for the “Best Pie Shops in America,” a Delaware County eatery was included.

To create a list of America’s top pie shops, 24/7 reviewed and compared ratings and reviews from various websites, including Yelp, Thrillist, Time Out, Food & Wine, Delish, and The Daily Meal, as well as local and regional sites, and made final selections based on editorial discretion. The selection process prioritized pie-focused shops, but also included bakeries with a more general focus or cafes that serve food if their pies were highly rated.

While some shops offer traditional pies like Dutch apple, lemon meringue, and coconut cream, there are numerous unique flavors and specialties to choose from. Seasonal pies, such as peach or wild blueberry, may require advance ordering, so it’s important to call ahead. For example, Four & Twenty Blackbirds in Brooklyn is renowned for its salty honey pie, while Dangerously Delicious in Baltimore features an extravagant “Elvis” peanut butter cream pie with toppings like bacon, chocolate, whipped cream, and bananas.

According to the post by author Josie Green, what local restaurant wowed the critics? It was Just Pies, located at 736 Northfield Road in Westerville.

Just Pies is a bakery that specializes in creating delicious, homemade pies. Their offerings are made with the freshest ingredients and are crafted to perfection, making them a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

From classic apple and cherry pies to more unique flavors like peanut butter and chocolate cream, there is a pie for every taste preference. In addition to their traditional pies, Just Pies also offers seasonal and holiday pies. These pies are made with seasonal ingredients and are only available during certain times of the year. Some of the most popular seasonal pies include pumpkin and pecan pies during the fall and winter months, and strawberry and blueberry pies during the summer months. These pies are perfect for adding a festive touch to any holiday or special occasion.

But Just Pies isn’t just about pies. They also offer a variety of other baked goods, such as cookies, muffins, and bread.

The article highlighted Just Pies’ Peach Riot (with blueberries and cherries). Sounds amazing! It can be read here.

Image by Pam Carter from Pixabay

Start Your Morning With 1808AM

Delivered free each weekday morning, 1808AM brings you important Delaware County and northern Franklin County news from 1808Delaware and other local media, all in one convenient update.

SUBSCRIBE TO 1808AM



Most 1808Delaware posts can now be shared freely on other sites, subject to our new Republishing Guidelines. More information can be obtained here.
You May Also Like

A New Kind Of Fast Casual At Evans Farm

A health-forward fast-casual newcomer adds fresh energy to Evans Farm’s growing food scene

Powell Commission To Consider Plan For New Pizza Restaurant

Plans will be reviewed for a new pizza restaurant at 150 West Case Road.

RiverWest Partners Details Delaware Depot Development

By 1808Delaware In a Wednesday interview with WDLR News, representatives of Columbus’…

Columbus Restaurant Weeks Debuts: A Celebration of Local Flavor

Two participating restaurants are located in the 1808Delaware coverage area.